| Position | 1st Allstar Team | 2nd Allstar Team |
| Goaltender | Andreai Proctor-Ramirez | Jared Whale |
| St. Albert Raiders | Calgary Buffaloes | |
| Right Defence | Breck McKinley | Lucas Watkins |
| St. Albert Raiders | Okotoks Bow Mark Oilers | |
| Left Defence | Tye Pedersen | Hale Schoneck |
| St. Albert Raiders | Calgary Buffaloes | |
| Center | Brett Hyland | Jayden Henderson |
| CAC Gregg Distributors | Red Deer Optimist Chiefs | |
| Right Wing | Liam Hughes | Ty Toews |
| CAC Gregg Distributors | Grande Peace Storm | |
| Left Wing | Heath Armstrong | Ethan Aucoin |
| Calgary Buffaloes | Calgary Northstars |
2018-2019
| Position | 1st Team Allstar | 2nd Team Allstar |
| Goaltender | Brayden Peters | Ryley Osland |
| Lethbridge Hurricanes | SSAC Athletics | |
| Right Defence | Ben Zloty | Tayler Miller |
| Calgary Royals | Lethbridge Hurricanes | |
| Left Defence | Dylan Witzke | Cade Mason |
| Calgary Buffaloes | Red Deer Optimist Chiefs | |
| Center | Brayden Morrison | Justin Ross |
| Calgary Flames | Calgary Buffaloes | |
| Right Wing | Michael Horon | Brett Meerman |
| Lethbridge Hurricanes | Red Deer Optimist Chiefs | |
| Left Wing | Curran Woods | Zack Stringer |
| CAC Gregg Distributors | Lethbridge Hurricanes |
2017-2018
| Position | 1st Team Allstar | 2nd Team Allstar |
| Goaltender | Carl Tetachuk | Duncan Hughes |
| Lethbridge Hurricanes | Red Deer Optimist Chiefs | |
| Right Defence | Tyler Winquist | Alexander Marrocco |
| Calgary Royals | Knights of Columbus Pats | |
| Left Defence | Neithan Salame | Eric Van Impe |
| Knights of Columbus Pats | Calgary Northstars | |
| Center | Ridly Greig | Brayden Tracey |
| Lethbridge Hurricanes | Calgary Northstars | |
| Right Wing | Jake Neighbours | Noah Boyko |
| Calgary Buffaloes | Fort Saskatchewan Rangers | |
| Left Wing | Layne Sniher | Carter Massier |
| Calgary Buffaloes | Grande Peace Storm |
2016-2017
| Position | 1st Team Allstar | 2nd Team Allstar |
| Goaltender | Logan Dyck | Justin Travis |
| Calgary Buffaloes | Red Deer Optimist Chiefs | |
| Right Defence | Cole Clayton | Zach Ashton |
| Foothills Bisons | Calgary Buffaloes | |
| Left Defence | Luke Bast | Matthew Robertson |
| Red Deer Optimist Chiefs | Sherwood Park Kings | |
| Center | Peyton Krebs | Zach Anderson |
| Foothills Bisons | Calgary Buffaloes | |
| Right Wing | Paycen Bjorklund | Graham Blanchette |
| Calgary Buffaloes | Sherwood Park Kings | |
| Left Wing | Eric Blanchette | Levi Glasman |
| Sherwood Park Kings | Red Deer Optimist Chiefs |
2015-2016
| Position | 1st Team Allstar | 2nd Team Allstar |
| Goaltender | Austin McGrath | Dawson Weatherill |
| Lloydminster Bobcats | Red Deer Optimist Chiefs | |
| Right Defence | Jonathan Tychonick | Ryan Schoettler |
| Calgary Flames | Lloydminster Bobcats | |
| Left Defence | Ty Smith | Daly Hamilton |
| Lloydminster Bobcats | Calgary Flames | |
| Center | Gary Haden | Zach Webb |
| Foothills Bison | MLAC Beverly Optimists | |
| Right Wing | Arjun Atwal | Bryce Kindopp |
| SSAC Athletics | Lloydminster Bobcats | |
| Left Wing | Zane Franklin | Kyle Gordon |
| Lloydminster Bobcats | Foothills Bison |
2014-2015
| Position | 1st Team Allstar | 2nd Team Allstar |
| Goaltender | Arik Weersink | Caiden Kreitz |
| Lethbridge Hurricanes | Calgary Royals | |
| Right Defence | Cale Makar | Adamu Tanaka |
| Calgary Flames | Calgary Buffaloes | |
| Left Defence | Reece Soukoroff | Clayton Eisler |
| Calgary Royals | CAC Gregg Distributors | |
| Center | Matt Phillips | Brandon Hagel |
| Calgary Buffaloes | Fort Saskatchewan Rangers | |
| Right Wing | Josh Giacomin | Andrew Marshall |
| Calgary Royals | CAC Gregg Distributors | |
| Left Wing | Nolan Yaremko | Parker Aucoin |
| Grande Prairie Storm | St. Albert Sports Raiders |
2013-2014
| Position | 1st Team Allstar | 2nd Team Allstar |
| Goaltender | Patrick Dea | Joey Desrosiers |
| St. Albert Sports Raiders | Leduc Chrysler Oil Kings | |
| Right Defence | Kale Clague | Gabe Bast |
| Lloydminster Bobcats | Red Deer Optimist Rebels | |
| Left Defence | Tristan Thompson | Max Lajoie |
| UFA Bisons | Calgary Royals | |
| Center | Mason Shaw | Noah Gregor |
| Lloydminster Bobcats | Leduc Chrysler Oil Kings | |
| Right Wing | Zach Fischer | Logan Ferguson |
| Lloydminster Bobcats | Calgary Royals | |
| Left Wing | Curtis Miske | Ross Heidt |
| Leduc Chrysler Oil Kings | Red Deer Optimist Rebels |
2012-2013
| Position | 1st Team Allstar | 2nd Team Allstar |
| Goaltender | Tanner McCorriston | Jayden Sittler |
| Knights of Columbus Pats | Red Deer Optimist Rebels | |
| Right Defence | Tyler Dea | Nic Charif |
| St. Albert Sports Raiders | SSAC Boston Pizza Athletics | |
| Left Defence | Colton Bobyk | Connor James |
| Red Deer Optimist Rebels | Lloydminster Bobcats | |
| Center | Giorgio Estephan | Nicholas Merkley |
| SSAC Boston Pizza Athletics | Calgary Buffaloes | |
| Right Wing | Riley Simpson | Braden Jakubowski |
| SSAC Boston Pizza Athletics | Leduc Chrysler Oil Kings | |
| Left Wing | Jake Debrusk | Matthew Gelinas |
| SSAC Boston Pizza Athletics | Calgary Royals |
